Intrepid saddles are great value for the price point. The Gold model is available in either printed or calfskin leather and features an interchangeable gullet system and wool flocked panels. They have all the features of a much more expensive saddle, but at an affordable price .
I second the collegiate! I have one and it is super awesome.
I have a Collegiate that I adore. Marcel Toulouse and Bates also have some lovely saddles and you can probably find a decently priced higher end saddle used.